Chocolate chip cookies are my favorite cookie. Not one of my favorites. My favorite. Back in 2024, I thought I had found the chocolate chip cookie in Santa Claus, Indiana. It was my favorite. Case closed. Then this year I tried a sourdough chocolate chip cookie that was even better. Well, darn. That planted the idea that someday I…
By the time I got around to choosing all of the recipes for this challenge, apparently TikTok had decided chocolate chip cookies were just going to be part of my personality for a while. Because that’s where I stumbled across yet another chocolate chip cookie rabbit hole. This time it wasn’t actually a cookie video…
If you’ve been following along with my chocolate chip cookie challenge, you know one of the recipes made the list because its creator very confidently declared that her chocolate chip cookies were the best. Naturally, people had opinions about that. One of those people was Mystic in the Kitchen. She showed up in the comments insisting…
Sometimes you have to give a cookie another chance. Even when you’re pretty sure you don’t like it. This is one of those cookies. The recipe comes from Sugar Spun Run, and I actually have a little history with it because I’ve already made it seven times. Yes. Seven. And now I’ve made it an…
There’s just something about a chocolate chip cookie. I think most of us have a memory tied to them—coming home from school and smelling cookies baking, sneaking one off the cooling rack, or watching somebody in your family make a batch from scratch. That was not my childhood. 😂 My mom didn’t bake. She didn’t…
There are certain words you probably shouldn’t use around me unless you’re prepared for me to question them. The best is apparently one of them. I was scrolling TikTok when I came across a video from Stable Side Farmstand about her chocolate chip cookies. Not just really good chocolate chip cookies. Not her favorite chocolate chip cookies. The BEST chocolate chip cookies….
Okay. I think we may have officially lost the plot. The chocolate chip cookie challenge started out reasonably enough. I wanted to test a bunch of different chocolate chip cookie recipes and see which one people actually liked best. Then I decided to add a store-bought cookie. That was already questionable. Then I bought Chewy…
If you ask my family for a chocolate chip cookie, there is a pretty good chance someone is going to ask, “Are you making Memaw Cookies?” Because in our family, they aren’t really called chocolate chip cookies anymore. They’re just Memaw Cookies. My mother-in-law’s name is Margaret, but honestly, I had to stop and think…
Okay. I’m just going to admit it. I cheated. I’m doing a chocolate chip cookie challenge. Eight different cookies. Same basic setup. Same pans. Same parchment paper. Same oven. Blind taste test. Nobody gets to know which recipe is which. And one of the contestants came from a tube. Yep. Pillsbury Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough….
I have a problem. I really like chocolate chip cookies. Actually, that’s probably putting it mildly. Chocolate chip cookies are my favorite cookie. For years, I was convinced I had already found my favorite. In 2024, I was coming home from Niagara Falls and stopped in Santa Claus, Indiana. I had a chocolate chip cookie…